r/funny Does not answer PMs May 15 '22 Wholesome 10 All-Seeing Upvote 2 Got the W 1 Doom 1 Silver 13 Gold 1 Go Vote! 1 Helpful 13 'MURICA 1

Going forward, comics may only be posted on Wednesdays and Sundays.

Hey there, folks!

As you're probably aware, there are quite a few very talented, very funny artists who offer their comics in /r/Funny... but there are also a growing number of "comics" here that are little more than low-effort ways of bypassing Rule 9. Moreover, subscribers have been expressing their concerns¹ that comics (of both varieties) almost always eclipse every other variety of content offered here.

Basically, on any given day, a poorly made comic featuring a stolen joke has a much better chance of being seen than something well-produced and original. Some of this is the fault of the "Ennui Engine," but it's also the result of there being so many comics posted in /r/Funny.

To address this, we're going to experiment with a new approach:

Going forward, comics may only be posted on Wednesdays and Sundays PDT (Pacific Daylight Time), and only by the people creating them.²

Our hopes with this are is twofold:

  1. By limiting "comic days" to two days a week, other original content will get the chance that it deserves.

  2. Wednesdays and Sundays will come to highlight – with the help of discerning voters, of course – the best comics submitted to the subreddit.³

Those of you who have had nothing better to do than read our rules and stay up to date on all of our announcements will know that we aren't really changing much, but even so, we wanted to mention the update, explain the reasons behind it, and give folks the chance to discuss⁴ everything.

We'll be trialing this over the next few weeks, and we may end up adjusting things⁵ slightly.

If you have any questions, comments, or suggestions, please feel free to share them here... and thank you, as always, for subscribing to /r/Funny!


¹ These concerns have ranged from eloquent critiques to "BLARGH BAD COMICS BAD!"

² That is to say, comics may only be posted by the people creating the comics. We're not sure who creates Wednesdays and Sundays.

³ We thought about "Comic Deathmatch Days" as a label, but we didn't want comedians to get startled and start attacking each other.

⁴ No doubt these discussions will be well-informed and well-thought-out, and definitely not text-based screaming matches.

⁵ This turn of phrase wouldn't have sounded naughty without this footnote.

1.6k Upvotes

397

u/Pizzacakecomic May 20 '22 edited May 20 '22 Silver Helpful

If people find the content funny, it gets voted to the top. Isn't that how this subreddit works?

As a comic creator, I take offense to you labeling our work as "low-effort" and "poorly made", or saying our jokes are "stolen". You are directly hurting artists with these irresponsible, biased labels

This work takes a lot of time and energy (and abuse) and its provided at no charge! You're free to downvote it and move on if it doesn't suit your tastes but you don't get to police what others enjoy, and shame on you for doing just that. Clearly this sub isn't for humor, it's for whatever the mods deem funny based on their own specific tastes.

You could at least mention r/comics or r/webcomics to help drive traffic there, or redirect the users to that subreddit. Feels like that would solve a lot of things.

135

u/PM_Me_Spicey_Boobs May 23 '22

It's not the mods. The people overwhelmingly wanted this.

95

u/Pizzacakecomic May 23 '22 edited May 25 '22

The mods are making this rule because comics are TOO popular...which would mean the people overwhelmingly want comics.

The problem is the sub is named "funny", which is too broad. If you're going to make only specific things allowed then we might as well dissolve the whole thing into different subreddits (funny videos, funny signs, funny pictures, funny pets, etc.)

74

u/TheSwedishExperience May 25 '22

Not necessarily how reddit works. There's kind of this snowball effect. One comic creator posts their comics, another creator sees it and say hey, I should do that too and get some views for my content. Then another one does the same. A lot of people posting comics doesn't mean users are overwhelmingly appreciating it. Any number of creators can post any number of comics any time. The entire sub could be filled with comics due to oversaturation rather than popularity, which I believe is what is happening here.

This doesn't mean they're low effort, I'm sure it takes a lot of time to make them. Sadly for creators people think it gotten to a point of there being far too many comics compared to other types of content, and frankly many aren't very clever nor humorous in my opinion. I do think three days a week is more reasonable though.

15

u/scboy1025 Aug 03 '22

The mod said called them low effect and low effort. So it obviously them trying to only allow what they seem fit. It’s cool they are the mod but allow things and not allowing them based on personal reasons if unfair to all comics

11

u/redfreebluehope Sep 08 '22

As you're probably aware, there are quite a few talented, very funny artists who offer their comics in r/Funny... but there are also a growing number of "comics" here that are little more than low-effort ways of bypassing Rule 9.

It sounds more like the mod called out plagiarizers.

They pointed out that there are both talented creators, and "low-effort" knock offs.

3

u/scboy1025 Sep 08 '22

But art is subjective so your still picking and choosing winners here lol. It’s all good I’m just here to read comments.

2

u/redfreebluehope Sep 08 '22

If it's just pure plagiarism, can it be art? Curious question.

And, otherwise, do we want to encourage plagiarism? I don't think the mods insistence that the original artist post their comics (though it does beg the question, what about mainstream comics, or comics that the original artist has given permission to someone else to post) is an issue, though I do question the insistence that comics only be posted on Wednesday and Sunday. That is a definite limit. Otherwise the post could be summed up as "please follow rule 9, and only original art for comics"

It's all good, I have fun either way.

→ More replies
→ More replies

22

u/KingStannisForever May 25 '22

Then why not made subredit specificaly for them?

14

u/DateAcademic8084 Jul 25 '22

I don't mind comics when they are funny. The issue is that about 85-90% of the comments are literally people just stating the obvious with zero attempt to be humorous, and they still get upvoted.

→ More replies

12

u/FlashyGravity Jun 27 '22

There is one

→ More replies

25

u/PM_Me_Spicey_Boobs May 25 '22

When there are 100 comics posted for every 10 non comic posts, of course many comics will get upvoted. It's all numbers game. If I go out to a club at night and then tell you the next day that I got 5 girl's numbers that makes me sound like a stud/ladies man right? When in reality I asked 200 girls for their numbers and got rejected by 195 girls and got 5 numbers.

43

u/Pizzacakecomic May 25 '22

I disagree. That ratio is way off, especially where artists are the only ones allowed to post their work. The ones people like were voted up, and the top page of funny was a good mix of many different things.

What's more likely is you think there are too many comics because you dislike them, so they stand out more to you. But you can't take it out on the artists, it's the people's choice. That's not an accident you can just explain away, voting for content is the whole premise of Reddit!

19

u/RazorOneSix May 25 '22

That’s dumb that you’d only be able to post on certain days of the week

34

u/phantheknee Jun 09 '22

Your comics are not funny to me.

12

u/SkoomaSalesAreUp Aug 25 '22

So downvote them

2

u/ajluis101 Sep 24 '22

See. It’s hard for me to downvote things, even though I should…

22

u/PM_Me_Spicey_Boobs May 25 '22

Ur just butt hurt because you can't take it that people are sick of things you make

26

u/PastyCrackerMayo Jun 02 '22

Go outside, kid.

20

u/Hekboi91 Jun 07 '22

Yeah, what he said

16

u/KINGxDMND Jul 18 '22

Ahh the ol' losing a valid argument so you attack them personally move. What a dick.

5

u/scboy1025 Aug 03 '22

If your the admin I hope you don’t have kids because they will be the most boring dull things ever because if you try to control people on the internet your probably they same way at home.

2

u/ajluis101 Sep 24 '22

Says the guy whose username is “PM me spicy boobs”, to an obviously woman creator. But that’s none of my business.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

3

u/huffmast Jul 06 '22

How do we know that? Just asking. I didn't ever see a problem

→ More replies

6

u/scboy1025 Aug 03 '22

No it’s the mods artistic suppression is still bad either way it negatively impacts an artist inspiration and ability to share work for others to enjoying

3

u/SkoomaSalesAreUp Aug 25 '22

If that were true the comics wouldn't be getting so many upvotes

→ More replies

20

u/tmotytmoty Jun 16 '22

yeah. If it's stupid and unfunny, user votes should take care of it. Who's upvoting dumb comics anyways? Could it be that mods are unintentionally battling karma-bots to the determent of the human user experience?

14

u/Pizzacakecomic Jun 16 '22

Love how everyone blames things they don't like being popular on "karma bots". Not happening, buddy

→ More replies

18

u/hevermind Jun 24 '22

All democracies eventually transition into dictatorships. This is the cyclical nature of humanity.

46

u/Carolake1 May 30 '22

The vast majority of the comics here are not funny, not original, and are poorly done. End of story.

Maybe yours is the exception, but honestly there is so much bad content it really wouldn’t be worth it even if it was one of the very few good ones.

5

u/SkoomaSalesAreUp Aug 25 '22

That applies to everything though not just comics... There are tons of r/aww post on r/funny that get upvoted like crazy too

11

u/TryingTimesComics Trying Times Jun 29 '22

100% agree. Thanks for posting this.

→ More replies

33

u/erhue May 23 '22

I agree with you... Unfortunately r/funny is one of the worst places to actually find funny content. It's hard for me to believe that creators like you who dedicate their time, effort and imagination to make original and unique things get so little appreciation from the mods. In any case, please know that you're always doing an amazing work and I really like your comics. Don't listen to negative people who don't ever bother creating anything, yet are quick to judge and be hurtful. You're great!

6

u/huffmast Jul 06 '22

Top votes comment rejects this... Haha. Seems like a F-up then.

16

u/phantheknee Jun 09 '22

So make it funny. 9 out of 10 comic strips are not funny and really do have low effort written all over. That’s not a biased label, or an attack. It’s just not funny

→ More replies

14

u/Campake May 21 '22

the r/funny mods dont appreciate pizzacake. i hate them all.

6

u/iForgot2Remember Aug 30 '22

If you put half of the effort that you put into complaining and whining about how people don't like your comics INTO your comics, you wouldn't have any issues making it to the top. It's apparent that you are a bit delusional about your talents at this point in your hobby.

8

u/AtebYngNghymraeg Sep 18 '22

The trouble is, most of the comics are crap. They get upvoted because the handful of people who do stop to read them upvoted them but the people who are tired of seeing low effort comics just scroll past and don't downvote.

Most of the comics posted aren't even vaguely funny except to people with a particularly undiscerning sense of humour.

Surely a better place would be /r/comics? At least then people know what they're getting. The comics are ruining this sub.

4

u/HollziewoodsIRL Sep 16 '22

Shut up , it’s not a personal attack. I see it on literally so many subreddits , great comics/memes/ posts etc can be made that are hilarious but someone practically copies it and posts it and they get all the karma and the awards.

Others will make a minimum effort post coping something just so they can say the same joke but not put in the work or just be silly so they can pass the rules.

It’s not based on you , or your neighbour , or your dog , it’s just people trying to sneak their way into getting upvotes.

And I think for a page like this , individual who like comics can have a dedicated day, this page isn’t called r/comics so don’t be upset when You don’t see one , on a day that’s not Wednesday.

Having a equal amount of content in variety to share is a good thing , it’s not a personal attack on one section , it’s a suggestion to better the subreddit

3

u/VoxulusQuarUn Sep 04 '22

I don't feel like they're being unfair. It's normal to limit different styles of media to different days of the week.

2

u/karmadovernater Sep 20 '22

They did state theres talented comics then there's the low end ones.

→ More replies

61

u/Ranryu May 15 '22 Gold Wholesome

Finally, we're free from "Anecdote"!

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

85

u/ProfessorSypher May 15 '22

Not to mention the authors who aren't so good... lmao...

But seriously, good change. It was getting annoying.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/ProfessorSypher May 20 '22

Thanks. You're very good at recognizing when a comment isn't relevant anymore.

→ More replies

26

u/positronflux May 19 '22

PRAISE YOU!

20

u/Historical-Food-9142 May 28 '22

I agree! Sundays and Wednesdays are still two days too many.

I’ve been automatically downvoting all comics unread for months now. Please take your efforts to r/comics for those that will appreciate your art.

23

u/TVACkEol Jun 09 '22

Good, comics are overwhelming this subreddit

17

u/MaximumTacolord May 22 '22

Oh no, it is Sunday. The reposts are going to have to contend with the comics for 24 whole hours!

57

u/JPJRANGER May 15 '22

Good, comics are overwhelming this subreddit

38

u/Boycubpiglet May 15 '22

90% of my block list is webcomic artists on this sub whose material is basically "DAE [common observation/feeling/experience]" and nothing else.

29

u/90daylimitedwarranty May 17 '22

The "fourth panel looking at the camera with the 'can you believe it?' look" is 90% of the comics here. There is literally no joke.

17

u/PM_Me_Spicey_Boobs May 23 '22

Yes I was getting so sick of them

23

u/polemism May 17 '22

The problem isn't limited to comics. Half the stuff on page 1 is just super lazy cat pics or dick jokes. Maybe mods should do some quality control, or idk, how do we raise the bar here?

7

u/JasonBall34 aPirateComic May 15 '22

Wow, footnotes do not display well at all on mobile web. Lol

8

u/CorndogFiddlesticks Jun 12 '22

this isn't funny

7

u/hevidudi Jul 19 '22

You may only be funny on Sundays and Wednesdays until told otherwise.

3

u/AtebYngNghymraeg Sep 18 '22

If they could at least try to be funny on those days it would be a step in the right direction. I'm yet to see a comic that's actually funny.

22

u/No_Fan_7047 May 24 '22

ah, the fun subreddit that has no fun allowed

11

u/ivanoski-007 May 29 '22

/r/funny is actually the un funniest place om all reddit, who actually finds the trash on this sub funny?

6

u/AtebYngNghymraeg Sep 18 '22

If the comics were actually funny this wouldn't be an issue. The vast majority are utter crap.

2

u/No_Fan_7047 Sep 19 '22

comedy is subjective buddy, also way to post on something 4 months old

8

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '22

This is just going to make it too confusing for everybody.

7

u/Aethari Jul 23 '22

Seems to be completely the opposite. The worthwhile content on this sub is 95% comics, 5% original videos. Then there's a wasteland of shitty rehosted clips and forwards from Grandma.

24

u/The-Red-Beard May 16 '22

Fantastic news. I've had to spend the last year blocking any and all comic accounts (I'm well past 50 at this point) so they didn't inundate my feed.

13

u/shook_- May 21 '22

Thank god

4

u/topchief1 Jun 19 '22

I don't mind comics when they are funny. The issue is that about 85-90% of the comments are literally people just stating the obvious with zero attempt to be humorous, and they still get upvoted.

4

u/SkoomaSalesAreUp Aug 25 '22

Can't you just force comics to have a tag that is filterable for those who don't like comics?

→ More replies

5

u/TheLoCoRaven Aug 29 '22

Going forward they should also be funny.

→ More replies

17

u/DeeDee_Z May 16 '22

Going from No-comic Wednesdays to ONLY 2X/week seems like a Rather Serious jump, for which I would ask a tiny bit more justification -- I.O.W., dropping from 6/wk to 2/wk seems kind of "harsh".

Likewise, I'm surprised that footnote 2 is necessary. Was it NOT the case previously that only comic creator could post their own work? (Seems like a bit of an oversight if non-authors could post.)

For those authors who release material 3x/wk or more, what do we expect?

  • One post per day, only 2x/wk, only their best work? OR
  • Two or 3 posts all at once on the permitted day?

Finally, are you expecting, explicitly or not, that non-comic posts will simply skip Wednesdays and Thursdays?

Or, perhaps I'm just old and naïve.

5

u/J8YDG9RTT8N2TG74YS7A May 21 '22

Was it NOT the case previously that only comic creator could post their own work? (Seems like a bit of an oversight if non-authors could post.)

Technically, no.

Anyone could submit a comic if it was a link to the page on the author's website.

Only the author could submit a direct image link or re-hosted comic.

This rule has now been removed.

→ More replies

3

u/Ruzkul Jun 01 '22

Unless its calvin and hobbes.

3

u/r-Leafs_sucks Jun 07 '22

Going forward is such an asshole thing only a boss would say. I'm outa' here

3

u/inkhaton Jul 07 '22

garbage rule - how about only show ads on wednesdays and sundays then

3

u/brunettecarolina Aug 31 '22

THAT is a funny rule!!!! 😂😂😂

→ More replies

12

u/Antarktical May 16 '22

I support this as I come here not for the comics but mainly becuase of the genuine spontaneous humoristic content so it makes sense to me to appy that moderation

→ More replies

2

u/adamantaversion02 May 28 '22

the authors who aren't so good

2

u/Calico_cat774 Jun 14 '22

So frag day and church

2

u/SANPres09 Jul 05 '22

Nice change. I look forward to seeing how it pans out.

2

u/waspiflab666 Jul 30 '22

How can we also avoid re-posts as I can't look back in time.

2

u/Logical-Barracuda326 Aug 01 '22

I have a funny story related to suicide. 3 years ago, when I was in the 7th grade, I had a fucking day. I wrote a math test for 2 that day, I came home and my parents yelled at me harshly, in addition to school, I worked part-time and was very tired. Then I felt fucked up and lonely, even though I was a big wide kid, I sat on the roof of our house and cried a lot, at that moment I thought my heart would just burst, it hurt a lot. I sat on the roof for a long time, but then when everyone was asleep I decided to suicide. I thought: Nothing will stop me, God himself wants me to do it. I had already hung the rope on the very last step of the stairs, made a loop and was about to leave for another world, but it turns out my older brother was "calming" himself that night and did not sleep, through the window he saw me hanging on the stairs without signs of life and how he screamed: What the fuck are you doing? Go to bed, you little fucker. I heard it already from the other world and was very scared, from which I woke up and changed my mind

2

u/scboy1025 Aug 03 '22

Everyone should get as many comics as you can find and post 10 everyday

2

u/Orangebeardo Aug 09 '22

I came here on a bad day, hoping to get a laugh. I opened the first 30 posts or so and I haven't seen a single post that made me laugh. Wtf is this sub?

→ More replies

2

u/actual_investor4fun Aug 21 '22

I'm fine with new comics on Sundays gives you the whole week to perfect your craft!

→ More replies

2

u/VoxulusQuarUn Sep 04 '22

I feel like you're being too lenient with having two comics days, but that's probably because I'm in the "Comics BAD" camp.

2

u/thesolarisknight Sep 11 '22

Lets just go backwards then

2

u/clorista May 15 '22

Comic artists get a "verified" flair, will gif makers who submit OC get flair like this as well?

3

u/staffell May 25 '22

Exactly - or any artist who provides regular funny content, for that matter. Why should comic artists exclusively get a pass??

4

u/moe-hong Jun 14 '22

That's the stupidest goddamn rule ever.

2

u/Bendymeatsuit May 15 '22

Deathmatch days, pleeease!

2

u/Antarktical Jun 06 '22

that's nice thanks guys!

1

u/Single-Researcher809 Jul 26 '22

Their limiting our creativity! Time to go cut off my ear.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/NotMrMusic Jun 04 '22

who does create Wednesday and Saturday anyway?

1

u/Namikis Jun 16 '22

Are you posting this to flex about the rock she is wearing? What about her manicure? Does she walk everywhere using her hands?

1

u/Beginning-Repair-163 Jun 16 '22

Bring on the roose!

1

u/web24jahedul Jun 21 '22

Your comics are funny to me.

1

u/Biscuitfeet Jun 24 '22

ป้ี้เปff8 8 x ff tgc8fvfrแป x8 vvfngr g89 rfffffffftตจtffมเดเดดดดดดดดดเเุทัด8n887จอจ จดอนนตนว

→ More replies

1

u/Arvid23 Jun 25 '22

Like newspapers.